In a shocking revelation, it has come to light that a doctor suspended by the Medical Council for forgery and prescription misuse was subsequently employed at Our Lady’s Hospital Navan. This incident has ignited widespread concern regarding the hiring practices within the Health Service Executive (HSE) and the potential risks posed to patient safety.​

Background of the Incident

Dr. Alaaeddin Almassri, originally from Gaza, Palestine, was suspended by the Medical Council after being found guilty of self-prescribing and forging a colleague’s signature. Despite this suspension, he secured a position as a registrar in the emergency department of Our Lady’s Hospital Navan, commencing his duties on July 8, 2024. This employment continued for 11 days before his suspension was discovered, leading to the termination of his contract on July 24, 2024.

Details of the Employment Process

The hiring process raises significant concerns

• Interview and Non-Disclosure: Dr. Almassri attended an interview on May 20, 2024, during which he failed to disclose that he was under investigation by the Medical Council. His suspension commenced on June 17, 2024, yet he signed his employment contract with Navan Hospital on the same day without informing the hospital of his suspension.
• Hospital’s Response: Upon learning of his suspension and the breach of contract, Navan Hospital terminated his employment on July 24, 2024.

Political and Public Reactions

The incident has prompted strong reactions from political figures:​

• Aontú TD Peadar Tóibín: Expressed deep concern over the situation, stating, “Forging prescriptions and impersonation of other doctors is shocking… We need to know if any patients suffered any adverse treatment from this doctor.” He called for a full investigation into the matter.
• Sinn Féin TD Darren O’Rourke: Highlighted the unacceptable nature of relying on voluntary disclosure for fitness-to-practice checks, emphasizing the need for maintained standards and a comprehensive review of the circumstances at Navan Hospital.

Implications for HSE’s Hiring Practices

This incident underscores critical flaws in the HSE’s hiring protocols:​

• Reliance on Self-Disclosure: The current system’s dependence on applicants to voluntarily disclose investigations or suspensions is inadequate and poses significant risks to patient safety.​
• Verification Processes: There is an evident need for more robust verification processes to ensure that healthcare professionals are fit to practice and do not have undisclosed sanctions or investigations.​

Calls for Systemic Reforms

In light of this incident, several reforms have been proposed:​

• Enhanced Background Checks: Implementing mandatory and comprehensive background checks for all healthcare professionals prior to employment.​
• Centralized Verification System: Establishing a centralized system within the HSE to verify the credentials and fitness-to-practice status of all medical practitioners.​
• Regular Audits: Conducting regular audits of hiring practices across all HSE-funded hospitals to ensure compliance with established protocols.​

The employment of a suspended doctor at Navan Hospital has illuminated significant gaps in the HSE’s hiring practices, raising concerns about patient safety and the integrity of healthcare services. It is imperative that the HSE undertakes immediate and comprehensive reforms to address these vulnerabilities, restore public trust, and ensure that such incidents do not recur.

For more stories and insights, visit It’s On

Instagram:@itson.ie

TikTok videos and information:@itson.ie