Public Transport

Public Transport or Political Failure? Irish Commuters Pay the Price

As Ireland heads to the polls on November 29, 2024, public safety on transport systems has emerged as a pressing concern among voters. With accounts of harassment, violence, and general unease circulating across social media and public forums, citizens are increasingly calling for action. While the National Transport Authority (NTA) has made strides to improve services, the safety of public transport remains a hot-button issue, drawing the attention of political parties and shaping the election debate.

Public Transport
(Credit: Ireland on a budget)

A Snapshot of Public Concerns

Discussions on platforms like Reddit and local media highlight frequent concerns faced by public transport users in Ireland. A Reddit user recounts witnessing a violent altercation on a bus after a football match, while another mentions verbal abuse on the Luas. These anecdotes point to a broader issue: passengers often feel unsafe, especially during evening hours and in areas with limited oversight.

Key concerns include:

  • Lack of Security: Many passengers report the absence of visible security personnel, particularly during peak hours and at night.
  • Antisocial Behavior: Incidents such as vandalism, verbal harassment, and even physical violence are not uncommon on buses, trains, and trams.
  • Poor Lighting and Design: Poorly lit stations and stops contribute to feelings of insecurity.
  • Infrequent Services: Long wait times can leave commuters stranded in unsafe locations for extended periods.

What the Data Says

The National Transport Authority’s (NTA) 2024 Security Report outlines the scope of the problem. According to the report:

  • 68% of surveyed passengers expressed concerns about safety while using public transport.
  • Incidents of antisocial behavior rose by 15% in the last two years, with the Luas and Dublin Bus seeing the highest reported rates.
  • Only 28% of passengers said they felt safe traveling late at night.

The NTA has taken measures such as increasing CCTV coverage and piloting community transport wardens, but many believe these efforts fall short.

Political Promises on Transport Safety

With the elections looming, political parties have addressed public transport safety in their manifestos:

  1. Fianna Fáil
    Fianna Fáil has pledged to establish a dedicated transport police unit, similar to systems in the UK. Micheál Martin emphasized that this unit would focus on reducing antisocial behavior and creating a safer environment for passengers.
  2. Fine Gael
    Fine Gael has proposed expanding the Garda Public Order Unit’s role to include patrolling major transport hubs and high-traffic routes. They also advocate for stricter penalties for individuals committing crimes on public transport.
  3. Sinn Féin
    Sinn Féin’s manifesto highlights investment in community outreach programs to address the root causes of antisocial behavior, alongside increased Garda presence on trains and buses.
  4. Green Party
    The Green Party’s focus is on infrastructural improvements, such as better lighting at stations and the introduction of “safe zones” equipped with emergency call buttons.

Voices of the People

Passengers have taken to social media and public forums to voice their frustrations. One Reddit user wrote, “Why should we rely on public transport if we can’t feel safe? We’re left to fend for ourselves.” Another shared their experience of being harassed late at night, lamenting the lack of visible security.

These personal accounts resonate with many voters who view public transport safety as a litmus test for government competency. As one Dublin commuter put it, “If the government can’t even secure our buses and trains, how can we trust them with larger issues?”

What Needs to Be Done?

To address safety concerns and improve public transport, experts suggest the following:

  1. Dedicated Transport Police: Deploying a dedicated force could deter antisocial behavior and provide immediate responses to incidents.
  2. Increased Surveillance: Expanding CCTV coverage and ensuring it is actively monitored could enhance security.
  3. Better Lighting and Design: Improving station and stop design would make these areas less vulnerable to crime.
  4. Community Engagement: Programs that address underlying social issues could reduce antisocial behavior in the long term.
  5. More Frequent Services: Reducing wait times would minimize the period passengers are exposed to potential risks.

Why This Matters for the Elections

Public transport safety has become more than just a commuter issue; it reflects broader concerns about governance, resource allocation, and community well-being. With political parties offering varied solutions, voters will need to decide which approach best aligns with their expectations.

For more stories and insights, visit It’s On

Instagram:@itson.ie

TikTok videos and information:@itson.ie

Share this content: