The case of Joe Maloney, who has been a fugitive for over five decades after poisoning his wife, June Maloney, is one of the most chilling and elusive mysteries in modern crime history. Joe Maloney’s story, which began in Rochester, New York, involves a deadly cocktail, a series of daring escapes, and an international manhunt that has left authorities baffled for years. Despite multiple attempts to apprehend him, Joe Maloney remains at large, possibly hiding in plain sight under a different identity.

The Tragic Murder of June Maloney

In March 1967, June Maloney, a 27-year-old nurse and mother of two, walked out on her husband, Joe Maloney, after enduring years of emotional and physical abuse. Their relationship had been tumultuous, with June confiding in friends about Joe’s temper. However, the couple agreed to an informal separation, allowing Joe to visit their two children whenever he wished.

On May 27, 1967, June attended her son’s fifth birthday party at Joe’s house. After the party, June complained of feeling unwell, telling friends that she had only had two drinks. The following day, June fell into a coma and was rushed to the hospital. Despite several medical tests, doctors were unable to determine the cause of her illness. Tragically, June never regained consciousness and died on June 5, 1967. Her autopsy revealed that she had ingested a lethal dose of methanol, a toxic chemical Joe had previously stolen from a friend’s chemistry lab.

Joe Maloney’s Daring Escape

Shortly after June’s death, Joe Maloney was arrested and charged with first-degree murder. However, against the advice of his attorney, Joe requested to be committed to the Rochester State Mental Hospital for psychiatric evaluation. Unbeknownst to authorities, Joe had previously worked at the hospital as a janitor and was familiar with its layout. Using this knowledge to his advantage, Joe duplicated a key and escaped just two weeks after being admitted, disappearing without a trace.

Five years later, in 1973, authorities were called to investigate a burglary in Dublin, Ireland, at the home of Michael O’Shea. Upon investigating O’Shea, police discovered that his fingerprints matched those of Joe Maloney, but because there was no extradition treaty between Ireland and the U.S. at the time, Maloney was not immediately arrested.

The Legal Maze: Ireland to America

In 1985, after the Irish Parliament ratified a new extradition treaty with the U.S., Joe Maloney, alias Michael O’Shea, was finally taken into custody. However, he refused to cooperate with authorities, denying his true identity and preventing photographs from being taken. Maloney was held without bail at Mountjoy Prison in Dublin for 14 months, during which time he attempted to escape twice.

In 1986, Maloney was released due to a legal technicality that invalidated the extradition treaty. After his release, he vanished yet again, and despite the treaty being re-ratified in 1987, no trace of Joe Maloney has been found since. Authorities believe he may have used his connections to the Irish Republican Army (IRA) to go underground and avoid capture.

The Unsolved Mystery Continues

To this day, Joe Maloney remains one of America’s most wanted fugitives. His story has been featured on Unsolved Mysteries and America’s Most Wanted, but no substantial leads have emerged. Now in his mid-80s, Maloney could be hiding in Canada, Ireland, or elsewhere in the world, living under a different name.

Despite the passage of time, Maloney’s case continues to captivate crime enthusiasts and investigators alike. His ability to evade capture for so long raises questions about how well-connected and resourceful he was. Could he have faked his death? Did he receive help from powerful friends? The mystery of Joe Maloney persists, leaving the victims’ families and the public without closure.

For more stories and insights, visit It’s On.

Instagram: @itson.ie

TikTok videos and information: @itson.ie