In a disturbing incident that has garnered significant attention, Dylan McMahon, a 30-year-old man from Kilpatrick, Kildangan, Monasterevin, Co Kildare, was sentenced to five years in prison for assaulting and robbing a sex worker in Athlone, Co Westmeath. The attack occurred on March 26, 2019, but the case reached its conclusion in early 2025. McMahon pleaded guilty to assault causing harm and robbery, leading to his sentencing at Mullingar Circuit Criminal Court.

Details of the Assault

The victim, a woman from the Dominican Republic, had been in Ireland for just four weeks and in Athlone for one day when the incident occurred. She had been working as an escort to support her family. McMahon contacted her through a website and arranged an appointment. Upon arrival, he requested to use the bathroom and inquired about her charges. The situation escalated when McMahon allegedly punched her in the face and body, dragged her by the hair into the bedroom, and retrieved a knife from the kitchen, threatening to “cut her neck” while demanding a refund.

The victim pleaded for her life, mentioning her family, but McMahon dismissed her pleas and demanded oral sex. In a bid to defend herself, she used pepper spray against him. McMahon then took between €400 to €600 and a watch valued at €105 before fleeing the scene, leaving behind his phone and wallet, which facilitated his arrest the following day. ​

Court Proceedings and Sentencing

During the court proceedings, McMahon admitted to the charges but disputed certain details, leading to a Newton hearing—a procedure to resolve factual discrepancies in a case. He claimed he sought the escort’s services due to depression following a breakup and expected a different woman. McMahon alleged that he couldn’t perform sexually, and when he requested a refund, the victim became aggressive and used pepper spray on him. He maintained that taking the money was merely reclaiming what he had paid.

Judge Keenan Johnson, presiding over the case, noted the severe trauma and humiliation suffered by the victim, emphasizing that she had already been exploited and was forced to provide services due to her dire circumstances. The judge set a headline sentence of nine years for the robbery but reduced it to six years, with one year suspended for three years, acknowledging McMahon’s guilty plea. A concurrent three-year sentence was imposed for the assault.

Victim’s Impact and Aftermath

The victim, who has since left Ireland, provided a statement via video link, expressing that she did not believe she would survive the ordeal. The traumatic experience has had a lasting impact on her, highlighting the profound consequences of such violent acts on individuals involved in sex work.

Broader Implications

This case underscores the vulnerabilities faced by sex workers, particularly those from marginalized communities or foreign nationals. It brings to light the dangers inherent in the profession and the urgent need for protective measures and support systems. The incident also raises questions about societal attitudes towards sex work and the importance of addressing the stigma and risks associated with it.​

Conclusion

The sentencing of Dylan McMahon serves as a stark reminder of the potential dangers sex workers face and the necessity for comprehensive legal and social frameworks to protect them. It also highlights the complexities involved in cases where personal narratives and societal issues intersect, emphasizing the need for a nuanced understanding and approach to such incidents.

For more stories and insights, visit It’s On

Instagram:@itson.ie

TikTok videos and information:@itson.ie