Netflix’s latest foray into the medical drama genre, ‘Pulse,’ has entered the streaming scene with ambitions of capturing audiences akin to predecessors like ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ and ‘ER.’ Despite a promising ensemble cast and high-stakes narratives, the series has faced criticism for its lack of originality and depth. This analysis delves into the show’s thematic elements, character dynamics, and the broader implications of its approach to sensitive topics.​

Plot Overview

Set against the backdrop of Miami’s Maguire Medical Center, ‘Pulse’ centers on Dr. Danielle “Danny” Simms, portrayed by Willa Fitzgerald. A third-year resident, Danny finds herself thrust into the role of interim chief resident following her accusation of sexual harassment against her former mentor and ex-lover, Dr. Xander Phillips (Colin Woodell). The narrative unfolds amidst the chaos of a hurricane and a catastrophic school bus crash, serving as catalysts for the unfolding drama. ​

Critical Reception

The series has been met with a spectrum of critiques, primarily focusing on its perceived lack of originality. Vulture’s review bluntly states, “‘Pulse’ is a ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ rip-off,” highlighting the show’s reliance on familiar tropes without offering fresh perspectives. Similarly, Vanity Fair remarks that ‘Pulse’ “feels like an AI-generated ‘Grey’s Anatomy,'” underscoring its derivative nature.

Handling of Sensitive Themes

A central plotline involves Danny’s accusation of sexual harassment against Dr. Phillips, a narrative choice that has drawn significant attention. Time magazine critiques the show’s execution, noting that ‘Pulse’ “just doesn’t know what to do with its #MeToo storyline,” suggesting a superficial treatment of complex issues. This sentiment is echoed by The Irish Times, which describes the series as a “soapy distraction,” implying a prioritization of melodrama over substantive exploration of serious themes.

Character Dynamics and Performances

The ensemble cast features notable performances, particularly from veteran actors. Justina Machado and Nestor Carbonell deliver compelling portrayals, though their contributions are somewhat overshadowed by underdeveloped lead characters. The Wrap’s review points out that the show “takes a beat to find its stride,” indicating potential in the cast’s chemistry that remains underexplored. ​

Comparisons to Genre Predecessors

‘Pulse’ inevitably draws comparisons to stalwarts of the medical drama genre. While ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ and ‘ER’ have set high benchmarks with their intricate character developments and authentic medical scenarios, ‘Pulse’ struggles to carve out a distinct identity. The Los Angeles Times observes that the series presents “a maelstrom of emotions and entanglements,” yet lacks the nuanced storytelling that defined its predecessors.

In its attempt to blend high-octane medical emergencies with complex interpersonal relationships, ‘Pulse’ falls short of delivering a compelling narrative that resonates with audiences. Its derivative nature and superficial handling of sensitive themes hinder its potential impact. While the series offers moments of intrigue, particularly through the performances of its seasoned actors, it ultimately fails to establish a unique pulse within the crowded landscape of medical dramas.

For more stories and insights, visit It’s On

Instagram:@itson.ie

TikTok videos and information:@itson.ie