Scott McCormick, 33, and his partner Helena Boshwick skipped paying for seat reservations on their Ryanair flight from Birmingham to Palma de Mallorca, believing they’d be fine sitting apart on a two‑hour trip. But when the plane was switched to a smaller aircraft, it meant fewer seats available—and one of them got booted at the gate.

McCormick recalls the moment: “That moment was a red flag… then they said only one seat remaining.” He and Helen refused to board separately and insisted on getting on the next flight together. Ryanair offered a refund and rebooking, but later denied one ticket reimbursement, charging them for the replacement ticket anyway. He also shared how Ryanair showed “no compassion or care”, accusing staff of being “deadpan” when he was nearly in tears.

Airline Explanation—It Wasn’t Overbooking

Ryanair responded stating this was not overbooking, but a last‑minute aircraft swap: the original 197‑seat Boeing 737‑8200 was replaced with a 189‑seat 737‑800—leaving one passenger without a seat. The airline followed EU regulations by offering rebooking on the next available flight. When McCormick’s partner declined the alternative, Ryanair said it wasn’t their fault and that the adult couple’s decision to avoid splitting triggered extra fees.

Are Price Hacks Worth the Risk?

This incident highlights the pitfalls of Ryanair’s “pay‑as‑you‑go” model, where every little upgrade—like seat reservations—costs extra. Skipping those so‑called tricks might save £5–£30 upfront, but could leave travelers scrambling when info changes.

Elaine Poon, a London travel expert, champions the “check‑in chicken” hack—checking in at the last moment to snag better unassigned seats. But McCormick’s experience proves this late‑check strategy can be risky. Without guaranteed seats, things can go very wrong.

Ryanair’s Business & PR Strategy

Despite stories like this, Ryanair remains Europe’s biggest low‑cost airline. Its marketing emphasizes low fares while accepting that most revenue comes from add‑ons and fees. Minimizing costs—no skybridges, single‑plane fleet, and secondary airports—helps keep base fares low.

Ryanair’s public communications highlight fairness and adherence to its policies, even in touchy situations, which often mitigates case-by-case backlash. High passenger volumes and low cost structure mean such incidents are statistically insignificant—and the income-generating extras outweigh reputational risks for most travelers.

Passenger Perspective: Empathy vs Policy

McCormick’s story sparked empathy on social media, with users accusing Ryanair of “selective discrimination,” questioning why young, childless travelers seemed targeted. Yet, the airline emphasises contractual clarity and its right to transfer or deny boarding based on seat availability.

This clash highlights a growing tension: passengers expect bags, seats and treats included. Ryanair sells a bare‑bones base fare—and most folks end up paying more once extras are added. Complaints often point to lack of flexibility and empathy at the gate.

Tips for Traveling Smart

1. Pay for seat reservations up front—the peace of mind can be worth the extra cost on shorter flights.
2. Check in late, but not too late—the “check‑in chicken” hack can pay off, but only if the airline doesn’t reassign seats or change planes.
3. Read the small print—Ryanair’s terms cover aircraft swaps, voluntary refusal and aviation laws, not “compensation.”
4. Use triggers—ask nicely—on other airlines, politely requesting seat or upgrade options might work at the gate; with Ryanair, it rarely does.

Final Takeaway

Flights shouldn’t feel like a gamble, but in Ryanair’s world, saving up front means trade-offs on service and flexibility. McCormick’s experience—traded separation for a full seat fee and emotional fallout—shows that the company’s business model is great for low prices, but leaves little room for empathy when things go sideways.

So, is Ryanair still worth the risk? For budget travelers, yes—but only with eyes wide open. Book smart, prepare for surprises, and be ready for the consequences of skipping that seat reservation.

For more stories and insights, visit It’s On

Instagram:@itson.ie

TikTok videos and information:@itson.ie