In a recent ruling, the High Court denied Ryanair permission to appeal the dismissal of its challenge against the proposed €200 million cargo underpass at Dublin Airport. This decision marks a significant development in the ongoing debate over infrastructure enhancements at one of Europe’s busiest airports.​

Background of the Proposed Underpass

The Dublin Airport Authority (DAA) has planned a 1.1-kilometer tunnel beneath the crosswind runway, aiming to improve access and safety on the airfield. The underpass is intended to segregate aircraft from ground vehicles, facilitating smoother operations and reducing potential hazards. According to the DAA, this infrastructure is crucial for the airport’s future operational requirements. ​

Ryanair’s Opposition to the Project

Ryanair, Europe’s largest low-cost carrier, has been a vocal opponent of the underpass project. The airline argued that the approval granted by An Bord Pleanála violated the European Commission’s Water Framework Directive, which seeks to protect water quality. Ryanair contended that the board failed to ensure the project would not jeopardize the status of surface water bodies. However, Mr. Justice Richard Humphreys dismissed this claim, stating that the airline did not provide sufficient evidence to demonstrate potential harm to water quality. ​

Additionally, Ryanair asserted that the development contradicted the Dublin Airport Local Area Plan due to the loss of two aircraft stands. While the judge acknowledged some merit in this argument, he noted that the airline’s reliance on Section 37(2) of the Planning and Development Act 2000 was misplaced, as this subsection does not apply to material contraventions of local area plans. ​

Court’s Rationale for Dismissal

In refusing Ryanair’s application to appeal, Mr. Justice Humphreys characterized the airline’s case as hinging on a minor technicality related to the inspector’s wording on a domestic law issue concerning the local area plan. He questioned whether it was in the public interest to delay infrastructure designed to prevent vehicles from crossing active runways over such a technicality. The judge concluded that allowing the appeal on this basis would be unjustified. ​

Community and Stakeholder Reactions

The proposed underpass has elicited varied responses from different stakeholders. In January 2023, the St Margaret’s The Ward Residents Group labeled the project a “total waste of money,” highlighting that the tunnel would cater to an average of fewer than four vehicle movements per hour. They argued that spending €200 million on such a project was illogical and unnecessary. ​

Conversely, the DAA maintains that the tunnel is essential for maintaining safety standards and meeting future operational needs. They emphasize that the underpass will facilitate the movement of cargo operators, fuel bowsers, tugs, loaders, steps, and catering trucks, all of which are integral to airport operations.

Implications for Dublin Airport’s Future

The High Court’s decision paves the way for the DAA to proceed with the underpass construction, barring any further legal obstacles. This development is part of a broader strategy to enhance Dublin Airport’s infrastructure, ensuring it can handle increasing passenger numbers and cargo operations efficiently.​

However, the controversy surrounding the project underscores the challenges of balancing large-scale infrastructure developments with environmental considerations and community interests. While the DAA argues that the underpass is vital for operational efficiency and safety, opponents question the project’s cost-effectiveness and potential environmental impact.​

The dismissal of Ryanair’s appeal marks a significant milestone in the progression of the Dublin Airport underpass project. As the DAA moves forward with its plans, it remains to be seen how this development will impact the airport’s operations and its relationship with stakeholders, including airlines, local communities, and environmental groups. The case highlights the complexities inherent in advancing major infrastructure projects within a framework that seeks to balance economic growth, environmental sustainability, and community well-being.

For more stories and insights, visit It’s On

Instagram:@itson.ie

TikTok videos and information:@itson.ie