In a night filled with tension, drama, and electrifying football, Newcastle United narrowly edged past Nottingham Forest in the Carabao Cup second round, winning 4-3 on penalties after a 1-1 draw. Sean Longstaff emerged as the hero for the Magpies, calmly converting the decisive penalty to send Eddie Howe’s side through to the next round. The match saw the return of Sandro Tonali, whose presence added a spark to an already charged atmosphere.

A Match of Two Halves

From the first whistle, it was clear that both teams were eager to make their mark. Nottingham Forest, playing in front of a passionate home crowd at the City Ground, started brightly. They pressed high and looked to take the game to Newcastle, who were still reeling from a disappointing start to their Premier League campaign. The breakthrough came for Forest when a well-worked move saw their forward slot home, sending the home fans into raptures.

However, Newcastle, known for their resilience, responded with determination. As the first half progressed, the Magpies began to find their rhythm, with Tonali pulling the strings in midfield. The Italian midfielder, returning from a brief absence, was instrumental in Newcastle’s fightback. His vision and range of passing allowed Newcastle to assert themselves, and it wasn’t long before their efforts paid off. A swift counter-attack saw Newcastle level the score, with their striker coolly finishing past the Forest goalkeeper.

A Battle of Wills in the Second Half

The second half was a cagey affair, with both sides wary of making a costly mistake. Forest continued to threaten on the break, while Newcastle looked to control possession and create openings. The introduction of fresh legs in the form of substitutes added a new dimension to the game, but neither side could find a breakthrough as the match edged closer to penalties.

Nottingham Forest’s defense held firm, with their goalkeeper making several crucial saves to keep his team in the contest. On the other side, Newcastle’s backline, marshaled by their experienced defenders, managed to withstand the pressure from Forest’s attackers. The tension was palpable as the final whistle blew, signaling the start of the dreaded penalty shootout.

The Penalty Shootout: A Test of Nerves

Penalty shootouts are always a test of character, and this one was no different. Nottingham Forest took the first penalty, converting with ease, but Newcastle quickly responded in kind. The shootout saw both teams trading successful spot-kicks, with neither goalkeeper able to make a decisive save in the early rounds.

The turning point came when Forest’s fourth penalty taker saw his effort crash off the post, handing the advantage to Newcastle. With the pressure mounting, Sean Longstaff stepped up for the Magpies. The Newcastle midfielder showed nerves of steel, sending the Forest keeper the wrong way and securing Newcastle’s passage to the next round.

Sandro Tonali’s Impact

One of the standout performers on the night was Sandro Tonali. The Italian midfielder’s return to the starting lineup was a welcome boost for Newcastle, and his performance did not disappoint. Tonali’s ability to dictate the tempo of the game and his composure on the ball were crucial in helping Newcastle wrest control from Forest, particularly in the second half. His vision and incisive passing provided Newcastle with the creativity they needed to break down a stubborn Forest defense.

After the match, Newcastle manager Eddie Howe praised Tonali’s influence, stating, “Sandro was exceptional tonight. He brings a different dimension to our midfield, and his experience in big games like this is invaluable.”

Looking Ahead

For Newcastle, this victory is more than just progression in the Carabao Cup—it’s a potential turning point in their season. After a shaky start in the Premier League, this hard-fought win could provide the confidence boost they need as they look to build momentum. For Nottingham Forest, despite the disappointment of defeat, there are plenty of positives to take from the performance. They pushed a strong Newcastle side to the limit and can take heart from their display as they turn their focus back to the league.

The Carabao Cup clash between Nottingham Forest and Newcastle United will be remembered as a thrilling encounter, full of drama and tension. Sean Longstaff’s decisive penalty and Sandro Tonali’s commanding performance were the highlights of a night that showcased the very best of cup football. As both teams reflect on the match, Newcastle will be buoyed by their hard-fought victory, while Forest can hold their heads high after pushing the Magpies all the way.

For more stories and insights, visit It’s On.

Instagram: @itson.ie

TikTok videos and information: @itson.ie