What if the cure for cancer had been written down 2,000 years ago—and lost in a fire? What if ancient civilisations knew the Earth circled the sun long before Copernicus? These are just some of the speculative whispers surrounding the Library of Alexandria, perhaps the most iconic and mysterious collection of human knowledge ever assembled.

Though its walls are long gone, the legacy—and the loss—of this ancient wonder continues to fascinate. So, what was it really? Who destroyed it? And what exactly was lost?

What Was the Library of Alexandria?

The Library of Alexandria, founded in the 3rd century BCE in the Egyptian city of Alexandria, was far more than a building full of scrolls. It was a cultural and intellectual powerhouse, designed to gather all the knowledge of the known world.

• Established under the rule of Ptolemy I or II, successors of Alexander the Great
• Housed an estimated 40,000 to 400,000 papyrus scrolls
• Aimed to acquire every book or scroll ever written—whether copied, purchased, or confiscated from ships docked in Alexandria
• Part of the Mouseion, a centre for research, science, and philosophy akin to a modern university

It attracted some of the ancient world’s greatest thinkers, including:

• Euclid, the father of geometry
• Eratosthenes, who calculated the Earth’s circumference
• Archimedes, legendary for his mathematical innovations
• Hypatia, a female philosopher and one of its last known scholars

How Did It All Go Wrong At The Library of Alexandria?

There is no single story of destruction—there are several, each with its own controversy.

1. Was it Julius Caesar?

• In 48 BCE, during a civil war in Egypt, Caesar ordered the burning of his own ships in the harbour.
• The flames are believed to have spread to Alexandria’s docks and possibly to storage facilities linked to the library.
• Thousands of scrolls may have perished, though there’s no definitive proof the main library burned at this time.

2. Did early Christians destroy it?

• In 391 CE, under Roman Emperor Theodosius I, pagan temples were shut down, and their texts were considered heretical.
• The Serapeum, thought to be a daughter-library or successor, was destroyed by a Christian mob.
• Many scholars see this as the final nail in the coffin for Alexandrian knowledge.

3. Was it the Muslims?

• A theory claims Caliph Omar ordered the burning of remaining scrolls in 642 CE, allegedly saying: “If the books agree with the Quran, they are unnecessary; if they disagree, they are dangerous.”
• Most historians agree this story is apocryphal, possibly invented centuries later.

What Was Inside the Alexandria Library?

We may never know for sure, but historians believe the library contained:

• The entire works of Homer, including lost epics
• Ancient medical texts with surgical techniques far ahead of their time
• Treatises on astronomy, physics, and mathematics—some lost forever
• Histories of Egypt, Persia, and Mesopotamia written by now-forgotten authors
• Sacred texts from India, Babylon, Greece, and beyond

Many believe the knowledge lost set humanity back hundreds—if not thousands—of years.

Why Does It Still Matter?

The Library of Alexandria is not just a historical curiosity—it’s a cautionary tale.

• It reminds us that knowledge can disappear without warning.
• It highlights the importance of archiving, translation, and free access to information.
• It shows how politics, religion, and war can destroy centuries of progress in a matter of days.

Is There a Modern Replacement?

Yes—and no.

• The Bibliotheca Alexandrina, opened in 2002 in Egypt, is a stunning homage to the ancient library, housing millions of books and digital resources.
• But the original contents of the ancient library? Gone. Possibly forever.

Final Thought

The tragedy of the Library of Alexandria lies not just in what was lost—but in what we’ll never know we lost. It’s a reminder that human knowledge is fragile, and that the greatest wisdom may not lie in what we’ve written, but in what we’ve failed to preserve.

Stay informed with itson.ie.